On Our Minds

Blog title with celebratory balloon graphic.
Celebrating 20 years of executive search for the social sector

This November, On-Ramps turns 20.

Milestones like this one have a way of making you look in two directions at once. Back, at everything and everyone that got us here. And forward, at the work we still want to do. 

The beginning

We long knew we wanted to go into business together—and we knew what we wanted to build: something that felt additive to society, interesting to us, and where we could love going to work every day.

We had some really bad ideas, which we won’t go into. And we had some good ideas we chose not to pursue. It took some time to find the right fit, but when we did, it checked every box.

So why a search firm?

Eventually, the two of us met a third partner who was interested in starting an executive search firm. Sarah had a long-standing interest in organizational planning and was fascinated by all aspects of people and culture. Michelle, who had worked both as a teacher and on Wall Street, was new to the field and energized by a steadfast belief there were better ways to access exceptional talent. And thus a company was born.

At the time, we saw something many firms overlooked: there was a lot of talent looking for different ways to work. They wanted flexibility in all its forms, from project-based assignments and remote work to part-time roles and four-day work weeks. So we built On-Ramps through a lens of innovation around work. 

Finding the focus

How did mission-driven organizations become our priority?

We started off in a couple of different sectors, one of them being the social sector. We quickly learned that work was not only where we were getting the most traction, but also the most fulfilling for us personally. By our third year, whenever a lead came in from a nonprofit, everyone on the team wanted it. We loved the culture of the sector. We loved the clients we got to talk to every day. And we loved being in conversations with people who consciously were changing the world. 

Hiring for mission-driven organizations is also where we saw the biggest gap. At the time, there weren’t a lot of shops in town that focused exclusively on mission-driven organizations, in part because people tended to think of the nonprofit sector as either low-budget grassroots groups or huge institutions. You want to work at a nonprofit? Go work at a small community-based organization, a university, or a big NGO. We very quickly realized the sector was much more diverse than that, with lots of interesting talent needs at organizations large, medium, and small. Serving those organizations and helping them recruit leaders from an equally diverse range of backgrounds became the mission we wanted to pursue. 

What do we do differently?

We asked ourselves: How do we build an organization that really understands how to recruit talent from the private, nonprofit, and public sectors into mission-driven organizations? 

The answer was a firm designed to reflect the mission focus of our clients while delivering the caliber of service you’d expect from the best search firms in any sector. We wanted to do more than just find good candidates. We worked with our clients to understand where their organization was headed and where each hire needed to fit into the story. Then we shaped the search around those goals.

A lot of companies at the time were approaching recruiting with the mindset, “We’ll pay you more and we’ll own you.” But candidates’ mindsets were shifting. We were in conversations with people who were asking, “What if I don’t want to maximize my income or be owned, but I still want to earn a good income and contribute to the world? What does that look like?” We were able to give unique insight into navigating that. 

And our clients were drawn to our approach, because they needed to be different. They couldn’t compete on compensation. 

Growing up

What were those early years like, and how did things change?

When we started, we were a very small team. “On-Ramps World Headquarters” was Sarah’s vacant second bedroom, complete with a homemade sign—and we got booted when she had a baby. The world headquarters was redeployed as a nursery, and we leased our first office space. Now we’re a team of roughly 40. 

As we grew, we realized how much better and smarter we could be with a bigger, more diverse team. Our growth came in spurts, and with each one, we brought on new people who thought differently about how we do the work. We grew not only in scale but in quality, because we had more people with more ideas contributing to the way we partnered with each other. 

With all that growth, what’s stayed the same?

From the day we started, we have been a values-driven firm. In the beginning, the three founders sat at Sarah’s dining room table and asked, “What do we really believe in?”

We’ve revisited our values about three times since then, but they continue to be what we use when we need to make hard decisions, when we think about changing our search processes, and when we hire. The people who have worked with On-Ramps will say our culture is one of our greatest strengths. We think that’s because we’ve always kept our values at the center of everything we do.

Is there values work we’ve done that feels particularly meaningful?

About a decade ago, we got much crisper about articulating equity because we care deeply about it. One of the things that keeps us motivated is a deep desire to see leadership that reflects all of society, and to see people evaluated fairly. There was a brief moment where most of society was in step with us, but now we’re seeing backlash—especially outside our sector. But for us, our commitment to equity stays a core value and motivator.

Lessons learned

Did On-Ramps have any make-or-break challenges that defined how we’d go forward?

We’ve been very steady. We’ve never been the kind of firm that hires people and, if it doesn’t work out, lets them all go. We face challenges, of course, but mostly the same ones everyone in society faces. COVID was challenging. The last couple of years have been challenging. We do our best. 

What have we changed our minds about over time?

Flexibility was central to our approach from day one, at a time when that was relatively innovative. Today, flexible and remote work are more common, and we’re glad to see the working world make the shift.

But for all our talk about flexibility, we still had things to unlearn about building culture across it. We hired people in New York because we believed culture came from all sitting together. We don’t think that anymore. Letting go of that belief really opened the aperture. We got a lot more rigorous and intentional about the work of connecting with people virtually, and that shaped our approach to candidates too. 

The drivers of success

What is the secret to On-Ramps’ success?

Our culture and our people are number one.

We consistently hire people whose primary motivation is doing great work and staying curious. We all deeply care about doing good work, and we want to be surrounded by people with those same standards. We are all life-long learners. 

Fostering that culture in the right way has been key. When we started this business, we were looking for a refuge from traditional workplace practices that drove people out of the workforce when they had young babies, or left them feeling unfulfilled as parents because of what they had to give to work. We didn’t want an either-or. 

You can care really deeply and do great work without a burnout culture. You don’t have to work 24/7. You can have a life. We give each other cover. It’s a no-questions-asked kind of cover, and it extends to everyone on our team. Somebody has a family emergency, says “I’m out,” and everyone says, “Got you.”

Another secret is being compatible as partners. Our strengths are complementary and our values are very similar. We look at problems in different ways, and that has been hugely powerful for us.

We also decided pretty early on that we were going to give each other feedback, and when it was hard, we were just going to lean in and do it. That wasn’t always easy—but extremely important. There were certainly some difficult moments. Even two extremely close friends have to build that trust, because you don’t usually give your friends professional feedback. But it got a lot easier and now it’s second nature. 

Looking back at two decades, what are we most proud of?

Our team and our alumni network. The people who work at On-Ramps now and the people who have worked here previously are an incredible group of humans, and it makes us super proud that so many have stayed in touch. Real bonds have been made.

And we’re equally proud of our clients and our placements. When we think about the number of leaders we’ve helped find their next homes over 20 years, that’s super exciting. 

We’re also very proud of our Net Promoter Score of 98. 😄

Looking ahead 

What do we hope the next chapter looks like?

We want to grow without sacrificing. So often, organizations grow and lose their consistency and quality, and we’ve seen too much of that in our sector. 

We’re also excited to continue growing with the sector. We’re on the precipice of a change in the world and in culture. In a lot of ways, related to funding and culture, our sector has had its legs cut out from under it for the last few years. But it’s not forever. What the people we work with are trying to change in the world is so fundamentally important, and we’re really excited for On-Ramps’ role in rebuilding the sector, better than ever. Here’s to the next chapter.

______________
 

On-Ramps is a search and consulting firm that serves mission-driven organizations in the social sector. We are deeply committed to helping create diverse, equitable, and inclusive workplaces. Together with our clients, we thoughtfully consider and address these topics throughout every step in our process.

Ready to learn more about our services or discuss your hiring needs? Drop us a line at info@on-ramps.com.